Report of the annual Customer Union & Save Our Bank Campaign Gathering
The annual Gathering of the Save Our Bank campaign and the Customer Union for Ethical Banking (CUEB) took place on 16th November at Ziferblat in Manchester and online.
Around 18 CUEB members and supporters were joined by three representatives of the Co-operative Bank - Lesley McPherson, Communications Director; Chris Larmer, Customer Experience Director; and Donald Kerr, SME Banking Director.
The Agenda was split into three parts: (1) engaging with the bank; (2) small business customers and ethics; and (3) next steps for the customer union on ownership.
Part 1: Engaging with the bank
Update from the bank: Lesley McPherson and Chris Larmer updated the Gathering on developments in since Andrew Bester joined the Bank in August 2018 as CEO:
- Bester has a personal commitment to raising the profile of its ethical stance as well as its profitability, and the bank has developed a brand campaign with the theme “for people with purpose”. Financially the bank is in a stronger position.
- The bank sees its stance on environmental issues as an important differentiator; the Bank has been carbon neutral for 12 years; staff were encouraged to participate in the recent climate strikes; and the Bank continues to decline potential customers involved in the fossil fuel industry.
- The bank has an ongoing partnership with Co-operatives UK called the Hive which has helped over 700 businesses in the UK start up using the co-operative model. They are in discussions about extending the programme beyond 2020. The bank also sponsored the Co-operatives UK Congress in Manchester.
- The bank has supported the homelessness charity Centre Point through raising funds and donating volunteer time.
- The bank campaigned with Refuge in 2015 and 2016 against financial abuse in relationships and helped developed a code of practice for the sector, helping ensure that financial abuse being included in the Government’s Domestic Abuse bill, now going through parliament.
- The bank has renewed its partnership with Amnesty International, including supporting a training programme for young activists in human rights and environmental campaigning, and encouraging customers to support the Write for Rights campaign.
- Chris Larmer highlighted Bester’s focus on customer needs as framing all of the bank’s actions.
- The bank’s programme to help customers who have debt problems has been widened into a joint scheme with the Citizens’ Advice Bureau.
- The bank is reviewing its Ethical Policy, a project last undertaken in 2015, and is seeking the support of the Customer Union in this process.
Customer Union members then had the chance to raise questions for the bank. Issues raised included:
- The bank commented that it has improved its screening of charity customers as part of its risk management since its closure of several charity account in 2014-5.
- The bank has withdrawn from big business and local authority accounts in favour of its priority of personal and SME accounts.
- The bank’s IT systems are being improved to protect customers from fraud.
- CUEB members commented that the telephone banking service has reduced its opening times and longer queues are frequent. The bank is monitoring this. Queueing in branches is also becoming common.
- To improve customer information and feedback, branches are holding customer forums.
Update from the Customer Union: CUEB director Shaun Fensom began by setting out the recognition agreement which CUEB and the Co-operative Bank (hereafter ‘the bank’) have agreed. This is the first time a UK business has recognised a union of its customers, and sets out that the parties to the agreement share common objectives and will meet regularly to discuss the bank’s Values and Ethics and any concerns the Union and its members may raise. The bank and CUEB later signed the recognition agreement together at the gathering. For more information on the recognition agreement, see here.
The Customer Union successfully raised an issue with the bank regarding a customer’s attempt to transfer funds to Sudan for charitable purposes, in response to which the bank unblocked the requested transfer.
The Customer Union also asked the bank if it would support its customers in joining the Global Climate Strike called in September 2019, and was pleased to see the bank lend prominent support to the movement, including joining marches in Manchester with its own branded banners.
External assurance and auditing of the bank’s ethical reporting: CUEB director Ryan Brightwell discussed the Customer Union’s successful advocacy with the bank for it to re-establish external assurance of its Values and Ethics report.
In 1998 the Coop Bank became the first bank to have its sustainability reporting externally audited. This external audit has occurred each year since, and is seen as crucial for ensuring external scrutiny of the bank’s Ethical Policy implementation. However the bank’s most Values & Ethics report was not externally audited. CUEB raised this issue with the bank and the bank has committed to reinstate auditing of its Values and Ethics reporting in the coming year. CUEB has presented a briefing paper setting out its recommendations
Part 2: The bank, its small business customers and ethics
Donald Kerr, director of SME Banking, described his work to improve the bank’s services to small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). The bank is offering free banking to SMEs for 30 months and is working with the Federation of Small Businesses and the Greater Manchester Chamber of Commerce to improve the banking process for SMEs. The bank’s definition of SMEs includes charities, not-for-profit companies and community initiative companies.
The bank also provides co-operatives with free banking.
The bank has a £50m grant from the Williams & Glyn fund for creating a banking mobile app and other SME business improvements. 2020 is expected to show the bank’s first growth in SME customers for some years. The bank will upgrade its online banking services for SMEs over the next 2 years.
Part 3: Next steps for the Customer Union
The Coop Bank representatives left the meeting for this part of the proceedings.
Ownership: CUEB director Rob Harrison reviewed the Customer Union’s goals on ownership and engagement and the current status of the bank’s ownership The majority of shares in the bank (70%) are owned by a group of private equity and hedge funds. These hedge funds are likely to seek an exit in the medium-term future, most likely after the bank returns to profitability.
This gives CUEB time to make sure this sale process includes factors beyond financial return, and that proper consideration is given to ethical issues and mutual ownership. To help develop a strategy on ownership, the CUEB board will approach appropriate people to join a new specialist panel to provide expert advice and guidance on CUEB’s options for supporting an eventual return to cooperative ownership.
Discussion: CUEB retains a small shareholding in the bank, although it has been devalued. Options to build this stake have been explored but since the shares are not publicly traded, there have been no opportunities to do so. Crowdfunding to grow this shareholding could be part of our strategy. However in hindsight it would have been irresponsible to have encouraged members to invest in the bank given the collapse in the value of shares since CUEB purchased its stake. Working to develop links with existing co-operatives which may have an interest in the bank was also discussed.
The meeting finished with all attendees sharing their final reflections and with the Union reaffirming its commitment to building a constructive relationship with the bank while continuing to hold the bank to account over its ethical commitments.